by Jorge Cham
You might think the title is a little exaggerated, but if there’s one thing I’ve learned from Theoretical Physicists so far, it’s to be bold with my conjectures about reality.
Welcome to the second installment of our series of animations about Quantum Information! After an auspicious start describing doing the impossible, this week we take a step back to talk in general terms about what makes the Quantum World different and how these differences can be used to build Quantum Computers.
In this video, I interviewed John Preskill and Spiros Michalakis. John is the co-Director of the Institute for Quantum Information and Matter. He’s known for many things, including making (and winning) bets with Stephen Hawking. Spiros hails from Greece, and probably never thought he’d see himself drawn in a Faustian devil outfit in the name of science (although, he’s so motivated about outreach, he’d probably do it).
In preparation to make this video, I thought I’d do what any serious writer would do to exhaustively research a complex topic like this: read the Wikipedia page and call it a day. But then, while visiting the local library with my son, I stumbled upon a small section of books about Quantum Physics aimed at a general audience.
I thought, “Great! I’ll read these books and learn that way!” When I opened the books, though, they were mostly all text. I’m not against text, but when you’re a busy* cartoonist on a deadline trying to learn one of the most complex topics humans have ever devised, a few figures would help. On the other hand, fewer graphics mean more job security for busy cartoonists, so I can’t really complain. (*=Not really).
In particular, I started to read “The Quantum Story: A History in 40 Moments” by Jim Baggott. First, telling a story in 40 moments sounds a lot like telling a story with comics, and second, I thought it would be great to learn about these concepts from the point of view of how they came up with them. So, I eagerly opened the book and here is what it says in the Preface:
“Nobody really understands how Quantum Theory actually works.”
“Niels Bohr claimed that anybody who is not shocked by the theory has not understood it… Richard Feynman went further: he claimed that nobody understands it.”
One page in, and it’s already telling me to give up.
It’s a fascinating read, I highly recommend the book. Baggott makes the claim that,
“The reality of Scientific Endeavor is profoundly messy, often illogical, deeply emotional, and driven by the individual personalities involved as they sleepwalk their way to a temporary scientific truth.”
I’m glad this history was recorded. I hope in a way that these videos help record a quantum of the developing story, as we humans try to create pockets of quantum weirdness that can scale up. As John says in the video, it is very exciting.
Now, if you’ll excuse me, I need to sleepwalk back to bed.
Watch the second installment of this series:
Jorge Cham is the creator of Piled Higher and Deeper (www.phdcomics.com).
CREDITS:
Featuring: John Preskill and Spiros Michalakis
Produced in Partnership with the Institute for Quantum Information and Matter (http://iqim.caltech.edu) at Caltech with funding provided by the National Science Foundation.
Animation Assistance: Meg Rosenburg
Transcription: Noel Dilworth
Have you seen Robin Wilke’s research in the Chaining problem? She found all sorts of counter examples and I have joked that she is the first quantum computer hacker.
can you link to her research?
Pingback: Secret Space War VIII: Alien Quantum Computing and the End of Secrecy? — State of Globe
Faust was the scholar. Mephistopheles was the devil.
Pingback: Awesome Animation About Quantum Computers « QuantumBlah
Reblogged this on My Educational Technology Blog: A Place of Resources and Tools for Educators and commented:
A MUST SEE
Pingback: Futureseek Daily Link Review; 23 August 2013 | Futureseek Link Digest
Very cool!
Reblogged this on I solemnly swear that i am up to no good ….
Pingback: Οι κβαντικοί υπολογιστές σε κινούμενα σχέδια | physicsgg
Pingback: Tech Thoughts Daily Net News – August 23, 2013 | Bill Mullins' Weblog - Tech Thoughts
Pingback: Animación sobre ordenadores cuánticos
Hey Jorge,
Being a Grad-student (soon to be ex-grad student) in this very same field. I can assure you one thing: Very very very little is impossible. And Decoherence isn’t really a big problem.
In my experiences understanding quantum is more like a fieldtrip in a large department store when you are four years of age. You can walk around on yourself. And once you let go of your peers that tell you where to go, you’ll immerse yourself in a world of exploration. Not limited but how things ‘should be’ or what ‘is not possible’. But simply but what you can see and think of is mostly possible. In Quantum engineering, theres is seldomly a ‘weird idea’. And it is the one science where wild fantasies are paying off more then whatever art-school could ever.
Cheers!
p.s. Check out Wheeler’s Delayed choice experiment.
The best analogies of the quantum info theory I have even seen in my life! In particular, I’m amazed by the number in the box, which if you will see “0” from one angle, but “1” from another one
Pingback: Quantum Information and Quantum Computing | In the Dark
Pingback: Why Programming a Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard | シ最愛遲到.!
Pingback: Why Programming a Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard — Blog of MPRosa
Cool for people who don’t know Q of Quantum Mechanics!
Yet another show-off from the Quantum Computing people. Keep it up!
(How else will you get the funding?)
Pingback: Video: The Coming Age of the Qubit – Quantum Computing Explained | insideHPC.com
Pingback: Why Programming a Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard — DesignProspective
Pingback: Why Programming a Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard | sievenews.com
Pingback: Why Programming a Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard « Robot Insurance
Pingback: The Most Awesome Animation About Quantum Computers You Will Ever See | Quantum Frontiers | A diary of a sys admin.
Pingback: Why Programming A Quantum Computer Is So Damn Hard | Gizmodo Australia
Pingback: Εκπληκτικό animated video για τους κβαντικούς υπολογιστές [Video]
Pingback: Εκπληκτικό animated video για τους κβαντικούς υπολογιστές [Video] | DigitalNews
Pingback: Εκπληκτικό animated video για τους κβαντικούς υπολογιστές [Video] - Inside News! - Inside News!
Pingback: Εκπληκτικό animated video για τους κβαντικούς υπολογιστές [Video] ‹ apworld
Pingback: Εκπληκτικό animated video για τους κβαντικούς υπολογιστές [Video] | PLIROFORIA
Pingback: The Quantum Story: A History in 40 Moments · WWW.INFOWEBHUB.NET
Pingback: The Most Awesome Animation About Quantum Comput...
Pingback: New Form Of Matter Made Of Photons Behaves Like Star Wars Lightsaber, Scientists Say «
super
super.,quantam computer is favorite subject .so I love quantam computing
Pingback: Quantum Computers animated!
Pingback: I have free will even if you don’t… | The Furloff
Pingback: I have free will even if you don’t…but maybe you do | The Furloff
Pingback: The Near and the Far: Motivations for Physics | 4 gravitons
Pingback: This Video Of Scientists Splitting An Electron Will Shock You | Quantum Frontiers
really great animation. and Mephistopheles was the devil.
Pingback: LETS BE GOOGLY SURE – NEWS SIEVE
Pingback: Quantum Is The Computing – News Sieve
Thanks for your advice. It helps us a lot. I will definitely try to apply them in the next protected or unprotected mock. Please keep us updating with your immense knowledge
Pingback: Quantum Computers Explained | So Long, and Thanks for All the Fish